I wouldn't rule that petrification by a monster could be countered by a Dispel Magic. Maybe if it happened from a Flesh to Stone spell.

However, I would agree that you go forward with your ruling for that session but note going forward that it wouldn't be viable in future sessions.

Unless you want to allow Dispel Magic as a way to reverse petrification that is.

Hyperborea is a very chaotic place. Just because it worked once, doesn't mean it will work next time.

Thanks for the replies! I was airing on the side of not allowing dispel magic to work again since the transformation isn't magical in nature, but just wanted to keep the game moving.

I do really like the idea that it could wear off or actually did work but might not in the future.

tomas wrote:

Given the situation as you explained it, the PC was stoned early in the night, I would have made the same call for the same reason unless there was a competent henchman for the player to run.

What you have now, is a great opportunity for a follow-on adventure; have the characters realize that the dispel magic solution is very temporary (say a month at best) and now they need to find a permanent solution (a proper stone-to-flesh spell, potion, scroll, etc.).

I like the temporary effect idea. Things get to move on and an adventure is generated. It also sets up the notion that nothing is locked in stone (no pun intended) and sorcery is not predictable.
 

ScooterMcGavin wrote:

This came up in my last session. Currently running my players through Charnel Crypt and the berserker in the party failed a save vs. transformation and was turned to stone. I did a quick search during the session and found casting Stone to Flesh will allow a person to be restored, but wanted to see if there are any other methods that could be used.

Another party member asked if the transformation was caused by magic and whether a Dispel Magic spell would reverse the change and I wasn't really sure what to tell them. For the sake of continuing the session, I allowed it, as it was early and it would have left the petrified player twiddling their thumbs for the rest of the evening. I did let my players know that I wasn't sure and would allow it this time around but would come back with a final decision later.

At the end of the day, I know it's whatever I choose to allow, but wanted to see what other people's thoughts were on this since I wasn't able to find anything else on the subject.

I would have looked at it like this. The act of Petrification may take a full round or more to complete. If a character casts a Dispell Magic "during" the transformation, I'd give it a chance to dispel the process, but significant amounts of damage may have been taken during the transformation. Once the transformation was complete, I'd go with only a stone to flesh spell would do to return them to normal.

That is just my opinion though. The world is yours, you make the rules/decisions as you wish...