Druvas wrote:
I finally finished the Kane stuff and was pleased with it. It was hard going at first. I think I was taken aback by the description of some blacks, but I put it in context and rolled with it. Upon further reflection, I'm not sure that he was being overtly racist so much as 'evolutionist' (does that make sense?).
I know what you mean. I first started reading Howard, Burroughs, E. E. "Doc" Smith, Lovecraft, etc. about fifth and sixth grade (1967-1969) and from there started gobbling up anthing "fantasy" and "science fiction" and have yet to stop. I still love that old stuff even though what I mostly read now is the modern stuff. I'm afraid that too many modern readers might feel that they are too "sophisticated" to read the old pulpy classics.
Beyond that, I'm not sure that love for these old classics will be passed on down to the next generation, particularly because of the way non-white races were referred to and portrayed. I can enjoy the old stuff because I can read them and accept them for what they were and not judge them by the standards of the world 80 years in their future. But then again, I was only about 30 - 45 years removed from their creation when I first read them so I cannot relate to what a new reader removed 80 years from their creation might think of them upon a first reading.
Are any of you aware that when Edgar Rice Burroughs, Inc. prepared the Tarzan series for paperback release in the early 1960 that they "cleaned up" the text and removed a LOT of offensive racial portrayals and dialog. That version of the texts have been standard now for about 55 years and even most devoted Burroughs fans don't know that what they're reading isn't the fully original texts. If you read some of the original pre-World War I text and are unprepared for it, you'll be shocked. But if you know the world as it was back then, you'll see that Burroughs isn't any worse than anyone else and, in fact, actually portrays some non-white characters with nobility and sympathy. But all of this can be a huge hurdle for a new reader of today.
Bowser