Being the Official Discussion Forum for HYPERBOREA®, a role-playing game of swords, sorcery, and weird science-fantasy
Visit us at the HYPERBOREA web site!
1 of 1- gizmomathboy
- Warlord
Online! 
- From: Spiral Mountain Array
- Registered: 5/19/2014
- Posts: 1,322
Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
An interesting series of questions from a player of mine.
I'm fairly confident in my rules for the everything but the last one I'm not sure on. My thoughts on it below.An interesting series of questions from a player of mine.
I'm fairly confident in my rules for the everything but the last one I'm not sure on. My thoughts on it below.
me wrote:
Do these choices stack? A player in melee may fight conservatively to trade an attack penalty of 2 for a +1 AC boost. Clearly, you can do this while doing a regular attack, but can you also do so while dodging or parry-and-blocking, both giving a +2 AC? (Blocking also uses attack bonuses from strength as defense) Clearly, there is no attack, so that attack penalty is for naught. Basically, can I defend myself for AC +5?
Dodging forfeits all attacks so no Conservative Fighting.
Parrying and Blocking also forgoes attacking so no Conservative Fighting.
It does let you use your ST attack bonus to up your AC bonus however.
Of these 2 actions, Parrying and Blocking give you an AC +4 bonus
Can I parry and block at the same time I'm off-hand parrying? This would give me AC +6?
Off-Hand Weapon Parry has an attack component so one can't Parry and Block while also Off-Hand Weapon Parrying.
Granted, I'm not gonna hit anyone when doing that, but given studded leather gets me AC 6, I think I could drop to AC 0 and untouchably waste some attacker's time while the Berserker's killing everyone else in the room.
So, if you want to go into full defensive mode using Parry and Block you can get an effective AC 2.
And, in two-weapon fighting assuming a broad sword (wc 2) as primary and either a dagger or short sword as secondary (wc 1), I should get a -2 penalty for primary and a -1 for the secondary, without my strength bonus. If, instead, I use the secondary for off-hand parrying, do I then lose the -2, regain the strength bonus, and hit like a perfect physical specimen again?
I think if you do Off-Hand Weapon Parry you get the +1 AC bonus. "as normal" is where I think things turn. Is that "normal melee attack", or "normal Two-Weapon Fighting attack"?
Let me ponder that last one a bit.
As I wrote, that "as normal" is where the ambiguity resides.
I think I would lean towards "normal attack" so they get to use their ST attack bonus.
Or, is Off-Hand Parry only available for Two-Weapon Fighting capable folks?
What? Me worry?
- Blackadder23
- The Thousand and First Eye
Offline 
- Registered: 3/04/2014
- Posts: 1,551
Re: Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
This is exactly why I don't use the predefined advanced combat actions. Players always looking for some loophole to get another +1 on something. 
Michael Sipe 1979-2018
Rest in peace, brother.
- Jimm.Iblis
- Adventurer
Offline
- From: Cincinnati
- Registered: 12/08/2017
- Posts: 289
Re: Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
They ought to have the two-weapon penalty on the main attack. Otherwise, a knife is as effective as a small shield {edit: in mêlée} and that doesn't seem correct. But kudos to your player for taking the time to actually try and learn the rules. Too few seem to be doing that these days.
Last edited by Jimm.Iblis (5/19/2021 4:24 pm)
"Role-playing isn't storytelling. If the dungeon master is directing it, it's not a game." ~ Gary Gygax
- gizmomathboy
- Warlord
Online!
- From: Spiral Mountain Array
- Registered: 5/19/2014
- Posts: 1,322
Re: Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
They ought to have the two-weapon penalty on the main attack. Otherwise, a knife is as effective as a small shield {edit: in mêlée} and that doesn't seem correct. But kudos to your player for taking the time to actually try and learn the rules. Too few seem to be doing that these days.
I generally don't do things unless the players also do them, so this also opens up possibilities for their opponents.
I had to read the actions because this is probably the first time a player used any advanced combat actions.
I can totally buy the argument that Off-Hand Parry is part of Two-Weapon Fighting.
What? Me worry?
- •
Thread Starter- rhialto
- Sorcerer of the 21st Aeon
Offline
- From: Shenandoah Riverbank
- Registered: 3/03/2014
- Posts: 797
Re: Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
Yeah, this is why I avoid the Advanced Combat Actions (and my players haven't ever tried to use them, or read them). But, I think I'd rule you can only stack ACA's where explicitly stated (e.g., with Dodge and Fighting Withdrawal), so Off-Hand Parry provides the benefits listed within its description only, not stacked with Two-Weapon Fighting.
"It is all very well to point out that the man lacks facility; as he asserts, sheer force can overpower sophistication."
Jack Vance, Rhialto the Marvellous
- gizmomathboy
- Warlord
Online!
- From: Spiral Mountain Array
- Registered: 5/19/2014
- Posts: 1,322
Re: Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
Yeah, this is why I avoid the Advanced Combat Actions (and my players haven't ever tried to use them, or read them). But, I think I'd rule you can only stack ACA's where explicitly stated (e.g., with Dodge and Fighting Withdrawal), so Off-Hand Parry provides the benefits listed within its description only, not stacked with Two-Weapon Fighting.
If you required Two-Weapon Fighting to use Off-Hand Parry then it becomes *worse* for the player/npc. This would mean that they can't use any ST bonus for attack *and* have a To-Hit penalty.
However, if you can't stack Two-Weapon Fighting with Off-Hand Parry then you get the AC Bonus *and* your normal attack gets any ST attack bonus and no To-Hit Penalty.
I'm not opposed to Advanced Combat Actions. As noted above it can cut both ways.
What? Me worry?
- •
Thread Starter- DMPrata
- Magister Litterarum
Offline
- From: US
- Registered: 3/02/2014
- Posts: 290
Re: Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
I’ve ruled that advanced combat actions can’t be stacked. The PC can perform one per round.
- gizmomathboy
- Warlord
Online!
- From: Spiral Mountain Array
- Registered: 5/19/2014
- Posts: 1,322
Re: Stacking Advanced Combat Actions
DMPrata is harsh but fair
Last edited by gizmomathboy (6/11/2021 6:58 am)
What? Me worry?
- •
Thread Starter
© 2009-2024 North Wind Adventures, LLC. “HYPERBOREA” is a registered trademark of North Wind Adventures, LLC. “Astonishing Swordsmen & Sorcerers of Hyperborea,” “AS&SH,” and all other North Wind Adventures product names and their respective logos are trademarks of North Wind Adventures, LLC in the USA and other countries. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.