!!insidediv!!



Being the Official Discussion Forum for HYPERBOREA®, a role-playing game of swords, sorcery, and weird science-fantasy


Visit us at the HYPERBOREA web site!


You are not logged in. Would you like to login or register?

Welcome to the Official Hyperborea Discussion Forums by North Wind Adventures!

  • Index
  •  » Swordsmen & Sorcerers
  •  » Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    • 1 of 1

     

    6/27/2018 9:03 am  #1

    mabon5127
    Pure-blooded Pict

    Offline

    From: Ptarmigan Rock
    Registered: 3/02/2014
    Posts: 1,238

    Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    Had a bit of a dust up with my daughter our last session concerning Mesmerize.  It says the enemy must be of animal intelligence. I ruled the centipedes were not and that is how it went. Though thinking about it various insects are fascinated by light and disturbed by vibration, so is sound a stretch.

    It sounds as though those things that are immune are "mindless" guided only by instinct.  What about bugs?

    “How can I wear the harness of toil
    And sweat at the daily round,
    While in my soul forever
    The drums of Pictdom sound?” 
     

    6/27/2018 9:36 am  #2

    Iron Ranger
    Wicked Woodsman

    Offline

    From: The Scorched Sanctuary
    Registered: 4/04/2014
    Posts: 3,872

    Re: Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    If a King Cobra can dance to the pungi....

     
     

    6/27/2018 10:19 am  #3

    Blackadder23
    The Thousand and First Eye

    Offline

    Registered: 3/04/2014
    Posts: 1,551

    Re: Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    I like to have an objective standard to follow wherever possible. Since AS&SH doesn't include intelligence ratings for monsters, if in doubt I would do what I usually do in these cases: look at AD&D. Giant centipedes are rated "Non-" for intelligence in the good old Monster Manual, so it would be no dice for your daughter (well, she could have dice; she just couldn't cast this spell successfully on a giant centipede in my game).
    I note in passing that snakes are rated "Animal" intelligence in MM2, so it would apply to them.

    Michael Sipe 1979-2018
    Rest in peace, brother.
     

    6/27/2018 5:45 pm  #4

    Jimm.Iblis
    Adventurer

    Offline

    From: Cincinnati
    Registered: 12/08/2017
    Posts: 289

    Re: Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    We understand quite a bit more about the intelligence of arthropods today than we did 40 years ago. The short answer is they are intelligent. The question then becomes: do want your retro-game to be informed by retro ooc ideas?

    "Role-playing isn't storytelling. If the dungeon master is directing it, it's not a game."  ~ Gary Gygax
     

    6/28/2018 6:43 am  #5

    ThornPlutonius
    Rogue

    Offline

    Registered: 3/14/2014
    Posts: 117

    Re: Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    Jimm.Iblis wrote:

    We understand quite a bit more about the intelligence of arthropods today than we did 40 years ago. The short answer is they are intelligent. The question then becomes: do want your retro-game to be informed by retro ooc ideas?

    Thank you for citing that very interesting article!

     

    6/28/2018 9:59 am  #6

    mabon5127
    Pure-blooded Pict

    Offline

    From: Ptarmigan Rock
    Registered: 3/02/2014
    Posts: 1,238

    Re: Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    Jimm.Iblis wrote:

    We understand quite a bit more about the intelligence of arthropods today than we did 40 years ago. The short answer is they are intelligent. The question then becomes: do want your retro-game to be informed by retro ooc ideas?

    Great article!  I never cease learning!  The hard part is admitting to my daughter that she had a better argument than she even knew!


     

    “How can I wear the harness of toil
    And sweat at the daily round,
    While in my soul forever
    The drums of Pictdom sound?” 
       •Thread Starter
     

    6/28/2018 10:02 am  #7

    mabon5127
    Pure-blooded Pict

    Offline

    From: Ptarmigan Rock
    Registered: 3/02/2014
    Posts: 1,238

    Re: Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    Blackadder23 wrote:

    I like to have an objective standard to follow wherever possible. Since AS&SH doesn't include intelligence ratings for monsters, if in doubt I would do what I usually do in these cases: look at AD&D. Giant centipedes are rated "Non-" for intelligence in the good old Monster Manual, so it would be no dice for your daughter (well, she could have dice; she just couldn't cast this spell successfully on a giant centipede in my game).
    I note in passing that snakes are rated "Animal" intelligence in MM2, so it would apply to them.

    This is the way it went thanks for the ref to MM2.
     

    “How can I wear the harness of toil
    And sweat at the daily round,
    While in my soul forever
    The drums of Pictdom sound?” 
       •Thread Starter
     

    6/28/2018 5:41 pm  #8

    Iron Ranger
    Wicked Woodsman

    Offline

    From: The Scorched Sanctuary
    Registered: 4/04/2014
    Posts: 3,872

    Re: Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    Blackadder23 wrote:


    I note in passing that snakes are rated "Animal" intelligence in MM2, so it would apply to them.

    Yes!!!

     
     

     

    1 of 1

  • Index
  •  » Swordsmen & Sorcerers
  •  »  Bard's Mesmerize vs Giant Centipedes

    • Board footera






    © 2009-2024 North Wind Adventures, LLC. “HYPERBOREA” is a registered trademark of North Wind Adventures, LLC. “Astonishing Swordsmen & Sorcerers of Hyperborea,” “AS&SH,” and all other North Wind Adventures product names and their respective logos are trademarks of North Wind Adventures, LLC in the USA and other countries. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.