Being the Official Discussion Forum for HYPERBOREA®, a role-playing game of swords, sorcery, and weird science-fantasy
Visit us at the HYPERBOREA web site!
1 of 1- Grimmshade
- Rogue
Offline 
- From: Anywhere games are sold
- Registered: 8/18/2017
- Posts: 122
Making daggers good?
I can't remember if I have brought this up here before.
The Assassin in my PC party is used to playing Thief types in 4th edition, 13th Age, Savage Worlds, and 2d20 Conan. In all of those games everyone has some sort of outstanding combat proficiency. One of the things I love about old school Class/Level games is that everyone isn't built around combat.
The problem I'm running into is the Assassin feels like since daggers are her weapons of choice, there should be some way to be more proficient at them (in essence, to get more damage out of them than a d4). This is certainly what backstab and assassinate are for, however I do understand her point that you are still better off using a sword for those actions.
To me its not an issue. It makes the character play different, as they should. I'm just wondering if anyone else has heard this complaint or has a PC who still uses daggers as weapons even though they have no advantage. (I remember this coming up back in the 70's/80's when playing D&D as well.)
"But not all men seek rest and peace; some are born with the spirit of the storm in their blood" -REH
Rambling Conan Blog
- Blackadder23
- The Thousand and First Eye
Offline
- Registered: 3/04/2014
- Posts: 1,551
Re: Making daggers good?
She could use a short sword and call it a dirk or something. Of course, then she couldn't throw it, but you can't have everything. 
It's your game, but I really think there's a limit on how much players should be indulged in this way. They always want to eat their cake and have it too. If they want to have a weapon that does more damage than a dagger, they should select a different weapon. If they want to improve their weapon damage with level, they should play a fighter class. If they insist on playing a non-fighter and using daggers, they should be prepared to accept the consequences of their choices. At least that's how I see it.
Last edited by Blackadder23 (1/24/2018 10:22 am)
Michael Sipe 1979-2018
Rest in peace, brother.
- Grimmshade
- Rogue
Offline
- From: Anywhere games are sold
- Registered: 8/18/2017
- Posts: 122
Re: Making daggers good?
BA23 - I'm in total agreement with you. I don't think Thieves and Assassins should be able to go straight up vs Fighters. Otherwise why play a Fighter class? A lot of modern games have this "eat it too" attitude, and I think it's spoiled specialized characters a bit.
I think maybe the solution is occasionally pointing out the cool things she can do that others can't, and if that doesn't help offering a different Class.
"But not all men seek rest and peace; some are born with the spirit of the storm in their blood" -REH
Rambling Conan Blog
- •
Thread Starter- rhialto
- Sorcerer of the 21st Aeon
Offline
- From: Shenandoah Riverbank
- Registered: 3/03/2014
- Posts: 797
Re: Making daggers good?
Daggers are good: when wielded by a Fighter who is a Grand Master of them. 
In all seriousness, I agree with BA23's point about the class distinctions: assassins aren't going to be as good at straight-up dagger-wielding as a fighter, period. Slipping one into someone's vitals when they're caught unaware, absolutely.
"It is all very well to point out that the man lacks facility; as he asserts, sheer force can overpower sophistication."
Jack Vance, Rhialto the Marvellous
- gizmomathboy
- Warlord
Offline
- From: Spiral Mountain Array
- Registered: 5/19/2014
- Posts: 1,322
Re: Making daggers good?
Yeah, there are reasons why the classes and such are the way they are.
Also, the downside is that NPCs will also have at least the same advantages you give the players. Not sure if players realize that.
What? Me worry?
- Handy Haversack
- The Monster of the Prophecy
Offline
- From: beyond the nighted gulfs
- Registered: 3/07/2014
- Posts: 1,799
Re: Making daggers good?
Daggers are also easy to conceal and don't weigh you down--possibly important for an assassin. Plus, you can carry a few of them.
- Grimmshade
- Rogue
Offline
- From: Anywhere games are sold
- Registered: 8/18/2017
- Posts: 122
Re: Making daggers good?
Great points all!
I was just thinking about the point Handy just made. The Assassin can carry a lot of daggers and not get weighed down. Plus, I would definitely allow her to have one or two sewn into clothing, etc., for concealing.
"But not all men seek rest and peace; some are born with the spirit of the storm in their blood" -REH
Rambling Conan Blog
- •
Thread Starter- BlackKnight
- Swordsman
Offline
- From: Central MA
- Registered: 1/24/2018
- Posts: 337
Re: Making daggers good?
A character that could use daggers good enough to stand toe to toe with a fighter, would be a fighter, if they want to be an assasin, then they need to play like an assasin, and no assasin would EVER try to stand toe to toe with a fighter.
--
BlackKnight, AKA Sausage
Older than Dirt, Crusty, and set in my ways. Been playing TTRPGs for over 45 years...
- Blackadder23
- The Thousand and First Eye
Offline
- Registered: 3/04/2014
- Posts: 1,551
Re: Making daggers good?
Assassins and witches are the only classes I allow to easily obtain poison (although they still have to pay for it or - the case of the witch - possibly brew it). If the assassin put even weak poison on her dagger, that would go a long way toward evening the odds, while still being class (and genre) appropriate. Of course, she would have to pay for the poison, and renew it on the blade regularly... because you can't have everything. 
Michael Sipe 1979-2018
Rest in peace, brother.
- BlackKnight
- Swordsman
Offline
- From: Central MA
- Registered: 1/24/2018
- Posts: 337
Re: Making daggers good?
Blackadder23 wrote:
Of course, she would have to pay for the poison, and renew it on the blade regularly... because you can't have everything.
Not to mention the care that must be taken while using it...
--
BlackKnight, AKA Sausage
Older than Dirt, Crusty, and set in my ways. Been playing TTRPGs for over 45 years...
- Handy Haversack
- The Monster of the Prophecy
Offline
- From: beyond the nighted gulfs
- Registered: 3/07/2014
- Posts: 1,799
Re: Making daggers good?
Of course, she would have to pay for the poison, and renew it on the blade regularly... because you can't have everything.
Not to mention the care that must be taken while using it...
And the insurance premiums . . .
- Grimmshade
- Rogue
Offline
- From: Anywhere games are sold
- Registered: 8/18/2017
- Posts: 122
Re: Making daggers good?
Good Idea BA23. I've doled out some poisons in treasure already, but maybe I need to remind her that she can use some of that loot pile to buy more.
"But not all men seek rest and peace; some are born with the spirit of the storm in their blood" -REH
Rambling Conan Blog
- •
Thread Starter- DMPrata
- Magister Litterarum
Offline
- From: US
- Registered: 3/02/2014
- Posts: 290
Re: Making daggers good?
If you’re using the optional advanced combat actions, your assassin has a couple of viable options. With superior DX, two-weapon fighting with a pair of daggers grants an extra attack at a minimal penalty. Even without high DX, a second dagger can be used for an off-hand parry, granting a +1 AC bonus versus melee attacks.
- Grimmshade
- Rogue
Offline
- From: Anywhere games are sold
- Registered: 8/18/2017
- Posts: 122
Re: Making daggers good?
Great options DMPrata. We are just starting to add more of the Advanced techniques, so I'll be sure to point those out.
"But not all men seek rest and peace; some are born with the spirit of the storm in their blood" -REH
Rambling Conan Blog
- •
Thread Starter
© 2009-2024 North Wind Adventures, LLC. “HYPERBOREA” is a registered trademark of North Wind Adventures, LLC. “Astonishing Swordsmen & Sorcerers of Hyperborea,” “AS&SH,” and all other North Wind Adventures product names and their respective logos are trademarks of North Wind Adventures, LLC in the USA and other countries. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.